Challenging essentialism

Urban Borderlands: Multiracial Histories and Gendered Borders in Los Angeles, Isabela Seong Leong Quintana, 2026, University of North Carolina Press

There has been significant attention to the formal policing of the national border in the southern US, a line in the sand established by dint of history, settler-colonialism and geopolitics.

This is the frontier policed by the federal state and its shock troops across multiple security agencies (there are too many to mention, and too many acronyms to bother spelling out: DHS, CBP, OFO, AMO, ICE, USCG, TSA, DoJ [DEA, FBI, ATF, OCDETF], DoD, DoI etc.)  

But borders also exist culturally within and between immigrant communities, and there are few better examples of this than in the melting pot of Los Angeles.

Isabela Seong Leong Quintana examines the “urban borderlands” that have existed historically in the city, in particular those distinguishing the separate yet also intermingled Mexican and Chinese communities—both of which reflect her own, mixed heritage.

Her book is about neighbourhoods in the vicinity of Los Angeles Plaza—the city’s historic centre established by its original Spanish colonial masters—from the 1870s to the 1930s, when ethnic Chinese and Mexican Angelenos lived in close proximity.

This was a period when US industrial capitalism relied on the labour of the Chinese and Mexicans while systematically excluding them from the rights associated with full citizenship, the so-called “national imaginary”, regardless of their legal existence.

LA is a key hub within the broader US-Mexico borderland, and as Leong Quintana notes borders are culturally constructed, recreated, and maintained not only through state geopolitics, policies, and laws but also through the ideas and practices of ordinary people on the ground.

In this sense, there exist “urban borderlands”, a concept that attempts to capture how the Chinese and Mexican Angeleno communities lived side by side in a rapidly developing city in ways that also reflected practices of inclusion and exclusion.

She writes: “Border-making is a locally specific process of inclusion and exclusion by ordinary people just as much as by the state and its elite actors. It produces myriad historical relationships, which affect the demographics of neighbourhoods and regions and their inscriptions of racial, gender, class, and other orderings.”

The author describes a certain bordering logic that prevailed in the Plaza area in this era, which depicted as “foreign” districts, worlds apart from mainstream America, the Chinese and Mexican neighbourhoods.

These were regarded by elite, white society as socially and spatially distinct both from each other and certainly from “civilised” Anglo-American spaces.

She notes that academic study of non-white communities in the US has overwhelmingly discussed Asian American and Latino histories as if they occurred separately and has examined racialisation only with respect to whiteness.

Yet, Leong Quintana writes: “This approach obscures the complexities with which practices of border-making affect different people at the same time and in similar ways across space and time. It also misses moments of similitude, familiarity, kinship, conflict, and collaboration among and between non-whites.”

Moreover, how these neighbourhoods negotiated their exclusion was shaped heavily by the gender dynamics of the era, in which working men predominated in these communities.

The author writes: “While exclusionary discourse around economic productivity and paid labour figured working Chinese and Mexican men as ‘problems’ for the nation, the growing presence of Chinese and Mexican women in spaces predominated by men signalled the imminent permanence of unwanted non-white populations and of interracial reproduction, all of which called reified national borders into question.”

Such phenomena have, as a result, made Chinese and Mexican women barely visible in the archival record and histories generally written by white, Anglo men—an issue that the author has sought to address partially through this study.

To do so, Leong Quintana adopts an approach known as “relational racialisation” that understands race “as a mutually constitutive and socially constructed process” that can counter essentialist approaches addressing racialised groups in isolation from one another.

This lens of “multiraciality” seems obvious when you point it out, yet surprisingly it is in its infancy, and Leong Quintana’s work represents a valuable addition to an emerging—and important—corpus of historical literature.

She writes: “… a field such as AsianLatinx studies disrupts previous monoracial frameworks of diaspora, mixed identity, and interethnic relations to (re)imagine a reality that situates the complexities of mixedness tangential to racialisation processes, identity formation, and transnationalism.”

Please help the Latin American Review of Books: you can subscribe on Substack, make a donation through Stripe . . . or just buy us a coffee

BUY THIS BOOK: UK/Europe

Categories: China, United States

Gavin O'Toole

I've spent much of my career in journalism and newspaper production: worked as a sub-editor and in other production roles at major UK newspapers including the Financial Times, The Guardian, The Observer and the Daily Telegraph / Sunday Telegraph. Covering business, finance, regulation, Latin American affairs and more. As a journalist and freelance writer I've contributed to many publications: work appears in outlets such as Al Jazeera, Public Finance, Global Government Forum, among others. Also an an award-winning writer of short stories and novelist. 

Tags:

Contribute to the discussion!